6 Potential Problems With Butcher Block Countertops

Discover problems with butcher block countertops, including maintenance and durability, and how to address them effectively.

A kitchen island with blue painted cabinet doors and a butcher block countertop on the end.
Image provided by The Kitchen Centre Ltd., customer

As a contractor or cabinet maker, you may wonder: Are butcher block countertops a good choice? What issues might come up? How can you solve them? Without the right care, these countertops can frustrate customers and tarnish your reputation. But by understanding the potential issues, you can deliver great results and avoid problems down the road.

At Cutting Edge, we’ve produced custom butcher block countertops for over 20 years. Each year, we craft about 20 butcher blocks. Our experience helps us understand the challenges these countertops can bring. We’re here to guide you through the problems and solutions so you can deliver great results for your customers.

In this article, you’ll discover six problems with butcher block countertops and how to handle them:

Knowing these issues will help you educate your customers and protect your reputation.

Problem 1: Butcher Block Countertops Need Yearly Maintenance

Butcher block countertops are wood, which moves and changes over time, even after installation. This movement means they need regular care to remain in peak condition. Your customers should recoat it at least once a year. This helps prevent drying, cracking, or other damage. Without this care, butcher blocks can lose their polished look and develop structural problems.

A freshly-oiled edge grain butcher block. In order to maintain the polished look, you or your customers should reoil butcher block countertops yearly.

Impact on You and Your Customers

Yearly maintenance can feel like a lot for some customers. If they aren’t prepared for this work or cost, they may regret their choice. They might even complain or blame you if you didn’t warn them. Neglecting maintenance can also make the countertops wear out faster, leading to more warranty claims or repair requests.

Solution

Set clear expectations with your customers. Explain why maintenance is important and what it involves. Recommend using a durable, food-safe finish like Odie’s Oil, which is durable and safe for food preparation. Provide a simple guide to help them care for their countertops. You could also offer maintenance services to build trust and long-term relationships.

Problem 2: Butcher Block Countertops Are Less Durable Than Stone

Butcher block countertops made with edge grain or end grain construction are stronger than standard wood. However, they are still softer than stone countertops like granite or quartz. This means they can dent, scratch, and show signs of wear, especially in busy kitchens.

An edge grain butcher block with dents and scratches. Butcher block countertops are not as durable as stone countertops, making them more likely to show damage.

Impact on You and Your Customers

Your customers may think butcher blocks are strong enough for their needs. If they weren’t told about the limitations, they might feel disappointed or frustrated if damage occurs. This can lead to complaints or negative reviews, harming your reputation. Repairs or refinishing to fix damage can add to your workload and costs.

Solution

Help your customers understand the differences between wood and stone. Explain that butcher blocks are less durable but offer a unique, warm look. You can also suggest they use cutting boards for food prep and avoid heavy impacts to protect the surface. You could even offer refinishing services to keep the countertops looking their best.

Problem 3: Butcher Block Countertops Are Not Heat Resistant

Unlike stone countertops like granite or quartz, wood does not handle heat well. Placing hot pots or pans on a butcher block can leave scorch marks. These marks are unsightly and hard to fix.

Impact on You and Your Customers

Customers might expect butcher blocks to handle heat like stone countertops. If they aren’t told about this difference, they may feel let down. Repairing heat damage can be expensive and time-consuming. If you don’t explain this upfront, it could harm your reputation.

Solution

Teach your customers how to protect their butcher block countertops. Recommend using trivets or heat pads under hot items. Suggest finishes that can handle moderate heat without discolouring. These steps can help prevent damage and keep your customers happy.

Problem 4: Water Exposure Can Damage Butcher Block Countertops

Butcher block countertops must be well-sealed. If not, they can absorb water, leading to stains, warping, or splitting. This is a common problem near sinks or in humid areas.

Butcher block countertops near sinks are susceptible to water damage.

Impact on You and Your Customers

Water damage can ruin the look of the countertop and require costly repairs. Customers may feel upset if they weren’t warned about this risk. Repair requests or warranty claims can take up your time and resources, plus damage your relationship with customers.

Solution

Use a high-quality, water-resistant finish and seal areas around sinks and other spots prone to water exposure. Teach your customers to clean up spills quickly and avoid leaving water on the countertop. These tips can help prevent water damage and keep your customers satisfied.

Problem 5: Butcher Block Countertops Aren’t Always Food-Safe

If your customers plan to use their butcher block for food prep, the finish matters. Some finishes contain chemicals that can seep into food and cause health risks, so using a food-safe finish is critical.

A butcher block with a knife resting on it. If you plan to prep food on your butcher block countertops, make sure you use a food-safe finish.

Impact on You and Your Customers

Customers may lose trust if they believe the finish on their countertop is unsafe. If someone gets sick from a chemical-laden finish, it could lead to liability issues. Even the perception of a harmful product can damage your reputation.

Solution

Always recommend or use food-safe finishes like Odie’s Oil. These finishes protect the wood while being safe for food prep. Clearly explain which finishes are food-safe and why they’re important. Offering pre-finished countertops with safe products can build confidence in your work.

Problem 6: Butcher Block Countertops Can Expand and Contract

Wood naturally expands and contracts with changes in humidity. The average butcher block countertop made of 15 boards can shift noticeably with seasonal changes, causing gaps, cracks, or bulges.

A butcher block countertop that has split and shifted over time. Butcher block countertops are wood, meaning they will shift with humidity changes.

Impact on You and Your Customers

Customers might not know that wood changes with humidity. If they see gaps or other issues, they may feel disappointed or misled. Repairs or adjustments can take up your time and hurt your reputation.

Solution

To address this, educate your customers about how wood reacts to humidity and recommend maintaining a stable indoor environment to minimize these effects. Plus, using proper installation techniques, such as allowing space for natural wood movement, can also help reduce the risk of noticeable shifts.

Ensuring Success with Butcher Block Countertops

Butcher block countertops can have challenges, but they’re also a beautiful and functional choice when cared for properly. By understanding and addressing these common problems, you can guide your customers and earn their trust.

At Cutting Edge, we’re committed to helping you deliver exceptional results. We provide high-quality butcher block countertops and expert advice to ensure your success. Discover how much butcher block countertops cost and take the next step in enhancing your projects.

Your Next Step To Working With Cutting Edge Download your guide to working with Cutting Edge for information about ordering, contractor accounts, pricing, lumber grades, and more.